By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support local journalism.
Auto bailout wildly successful
Placeholder Image

Weeks after voters dissed the Democrats, an important economic benchmark was passed with little public notice: The U.S. government sold off its stake in Ally Financial, the auto financing company once known as GMAC. It even made money on the deal -- about $2.4 billion.
That sale ended the six-year effort to rescue the American auto industry from financial disaster. Treasury Secretary Jacob Lew was correct in saying, "This program worked."
In 2014, American carmakers sold 16.5 million vehicles, their best year in almost a decade. That boom fits into a broader picture of economic progress: declining unemployment, soaring stock prices, steady inflation and interest rates. But President Obama has gotten little credit for those successes.
Last November, voters were gripped by gloom, even as they crowded into car showrooms. In exit polls, 3 out of 4 expressed anxiety about the economy's direction this year. Half said living standards would decline for the next generation.
That's why the president took to the road this week, visiting Detroit and other cities to reinforce Lew's message: The economy is rising. The program works.
But as the president starts his final two years in office, it's worth remembering what the economy looked like when he entered the White House. It was threatening to collapse. Depression loomed. Emergency measures were necessary. Large bipartisan majorities in Congress passed -- and President Bush signed -- a measure in October 2008 creating the Troubled Asset Relief Program, or TARP.
Saving Ally Financial and the big automakers was only one part of a much larger strategy to protect banks, brokers and insurance companies from insolvency. All told, the government disbursed $426.4 billion and got back $441.7 billion, turning a tidy profit of $15.3 billion.
Doug Elliott, an economist at the Brookings Institution, told the Wall Street Journal that TARP's "benefits in stabilizing the financial system and the economy as a whole were worth hundreds of billions of dollars, and yet it turned out to be essentially free. I call it the best large federal program ever to be despised by the public."
The Center for Automotive Research estimates that TARP saved 1.2 million auto industry jobs; the president says another 500,000 have been created. And that doesn't include the services patronized in turn by those autoworkers: dentists, dry cleaners, day care centers.
Perhaps the biggest flaw was the message sent to large financial institutions: If you take bad risks, the government will protect you anyway.
This is a messy world. Choices have to be made. TARP had a downside, but on balance, it was the right course at the right time.
This debate is not just about the past, however; it's about the future. The tea partyers and the Warrenites, who continue to deny the value of TARP, cast doubt on their own judgment. How can they be trusted to lead on other issues if they were so misguided on this one?
Steve and Cokie Roberts can be contacted by email at